Harlan McCraney: Presidential Speechalist
If you have never seen this parody of the speechwriting genius behind President Bush you are in for a treat.
If you have never seen this parody of the speechwriting genius behind President Bush you are in for a treat.
Since leaving England in the mid-1970’s I’ve often wondered what my life would’ve been like if that University in Medford, MA had not come up with the last minute offer of a full scholarship. I turned down a place at Bath University to come over and do postgraduate studies in the States.

But what if? What if I had not received that offer? I imagine my counter-factual English alter-ego in a Cotswold village penning learned articles and supping cider. Driving on the left side of the road. Raising children who speak with English accents. Enjoying afternoon teas in the faculty lounge and cricket on the television.
But I never really considered if my health and wellbeing would have been different. If anything, a routine of pints in the pub and chips with everything might not have sustained me as well as my current abstemious love of green tea and year-round California salads.
How wrong I am.
A study that appeared in May in the Journal of the American Medical Association was the basis for a fascinating article (subscription required) in Friday’s edition of the Financial Times.
The study presents damning evidence that Americans in the 55-64 age group are sicker than English people. Although the study echoes previous research in showing that, in both countries, rates of disease increase as socio-economic status declines, the national differences were so great that those at the top of the income and education scale in the US suffered diabetes and heart disease at a similar rate to those at the bottom of the scale in England. Stated plainly: the Harvard-educated elite were as unhealthy as the chip-butty munching navvies in the backstreets of Salford.
This despite the well-known statistic that Americans pay double the British for healthcare.
One of the study’s authors notes “We have to go beyond first-order explanations such as obesity, smoking and drinking to something more profound.”
A competitive culture must play a part, write FT columnists Christopher Bowe and Clive Cookson, highlighting the intense competition, economic insecurity and high levels of stress that run through American society. This, more than lifestyle factors – particularly the fact that Americans are fatter on average than the English and take less exercise – is statistically significant. The FT notes that stress is a BAD THING:
The body reacts to stress by increasing blood pressure and heart rate to transfer energy to muscles, and by enhancing immune defences, cognition and sensory functions. At the same time, it defers longer-term processes not needed for immediate survival, such as growth, tissue repair and reproduction. Chronic stress can cause disease… If energy is constantly mobilised and not stored, it can bring an increased risk of insulin-resistant diabetes. Persistent hypertension can damage blood vessels and, if combined with metabolic stress responses, lead to clogged arteries.
Maybe tending the roses around the doorway of my Cotswold cottages would have been a better option in the long run. Sigh.
Thanks to Joel for altering me a great source of useful videos (no, it’s not YouTube). My favorite corporate pranksters, The Yes Men, are featured on a number of clips. In addition to spoofing audiences as bogus representatives of the WTO, they have taken to the streets urging Americans to sign a petition in support of Global Warming.
Since there will probably be a backlash to this week’s historic legislation in California designed to limit greenhouse gasses, you should take a moment to see the response of the Joe Six-pack to some very improbable claims that the Yes Men make when asking people to support climate change. They don’t go as far as claiming carbon dioxide actually is good for you. I mean, no-one would ever think of funding a national advertising campaign making such a ridiculous claim, would they?
Watch:
OK, I’ve decided to drop the predictable sequence for these blog reviews. Rather than proceeding down the Blogroll, I’ll choose candidates to review randomly and keep everyone guessing who I’ll choose next. Adding additional spice to the current review is the fact that I’m taking a look at one of the few anonymous blogs posted by a member of the National Speakers Association.
The Dating Goddess’s Adventures in Dating After 40

Blogging since: May 8, 2006
Posting Frequency: Daily
Post Length: 500 words average
Aesthetic Appeal: Clean, uncluttered WordPress template. Abbreviating posts adds to readability.
Graphics: None
Categories: Attitude, BBW dating, Dating after 40, Dating chemistry, Dating Internet, Dating online, Greeting your date, Meeting your date, Releasing your date, Senior dating.
Blogroll: 13 NSA friends, including mine – thanks DG!
Target Audience: Single women over 40.
Comments allowed: Yes
Trackbacks: Yes
Alexa.com traffic ranking: N/A
Sites that link to this blog: N/A
Yahoo Links: 127
Review:
This is a hugely successful blog! It’s doubly intriguing to review. First, the anonymous “Dating Goddess” bills herself as “a 51-year-old white, professional woman. My husband of nearly 20 years left me 3 years ago and I started dating 18 months ago.” She claims to have been on over 60 dates in that time (phew!). Second, she bills the blog as for women only. So (as a happily married 54-year-old male) I feel like I am eavesdropping at the door of the women’s room when reading the posts of the DG.
I am in fact privy to her actual identity, but honor-bound not to reveal it, except to confirm she’s a bona-fide NSA member in good standing, and hence qualifies for this review.
Despite not finding any stats on alexa.com her blog has been listed by WordPress.com as one of the fastest growing on the internet – moving to 37th position on their list.
The DG is able to keep up a furious level of activity (seven dates with six guys in five days) because she is very much a DG of the 21st Century: on-line internet enabled introductions are the wellspring of her love-life. She uses her blog as a water-cooler where the girls can share stories of their hunt for the elusive Mr. Right. The DG is unabashed:
My idea of dating has been like going to Baskin-Robbins. I had vanilla for 20 years (maybe it was Rocky Road at the end!). While I enjoyed vanilla, I want to try new flavors. I didn’t want to jump from vanilla and make a commitment to butter pecan without having at least had a little taste of pistachio, chocolate, mint chip, etc.
So I made the list of men I would like to try. I like smart men, so wanted to try a lawyer, doctor, CEO, and venture capitalist. I like larger men, so wanted to try an ex-pro football player and ex-pro basketball player. I love men with accents, so wanted to try some from other countries. You get the picture. I had dates with all of the above, and more.
Her readers are a vocal lot. She often gets 7-10 comments on a post.
She is aware of the risks of today’s single lifestyle:
So beware. The dating dance can be habit forming. Watch out if you find yourself constantly searching the dealers (online dating sites), and be careful of doing things you know are not in your best interest (dating a guy you know isn’t a good match) just to get your high.
She faces the hard facts of STD’s (Sexually transmitted diseases) as well as dealing with the lighter side of dating:
In terms of suggestions for how the DG could improve her blog I have none, absolutely zilch. Perhaps a few single women would care the leave comments below (I’ll be sure to pass them on the DG).
I do wonder what kind of Goddess she is? Venus on the half-shell? Isis, kneeling before the coffin? The thousand-eyed, thousand-armed bodhisattva Kwan Yin, consoling all beings, or the Mother Shakti, the primal energy of the universe, ready to chop your head off?
I also wonder what a blog written by a man who’d had sixty dates in a few months would read like? Less an honest appraisal of the pitfalls and advantages of internet dating and more a listing of the techniques to get laid found in The Game?
I wish the DG god speed and hope her blog has a short life-span. Hopefully, she finds Mr. Right and is able to move on to the Bride-to-Be blog, the Honeymooner’s blog and the Newlywed’s blog. Meanwhile , if you are a single woman looking for love in all the wrong places check out the Dating Goddess, she’ll set you on the right track.
He that is proud eats up himself: pride is
his own glass, his own trumpet, his own chronicle;
and whatever praises itself but in the deed, devours
the deed in the praise.Shakespeare: Troilus and Cressida: II, iii
The main task of a CEO is to communicate the essence of a company. Leaders are in a unique position to see the whole elephant and best convey the mission, vision and strategy of the entire company. As leaders, their personal integrity and style is inseparable from that of the company. In their hey-day Jobs embodied Apple; McNealy, Sun; Welch, GE. As with Presidents, Premiers and Prime Ministers, they embody the state — as Louis XIV said: L’État, c’est moi.
I’ve recently come across a series of articles that have me thinking about the challenge CEO’s face in cultivating a healthy ego and the risks for those who run amok in Narcissistic absorption. The articles I read raise questions both for leaders and those who provide communications counsel to them.
Francesco Guerrera’s insightful article (subscription required) in Saturday’s FT started the ball rolling: Forget the salary packages, look at the size of their egos evaluates Arijit Chatterjee’s and Donald C. Hambrick ‘s Penn State University paper It’s All About Me: Narcissistic CEOs and Their Effects on Company Strategy and Performance .
The FT article was blogged by none less than Richard Edelman. He makes four great suggestions to achieve balance between ego gratification and self-effacement (dare to win; don’t focus all company communications on the CEO; keep a constant long-term message; partner for success). However, I think he misses the real critique of Narcissistic CEO’s when he takes Guerrera to task for suggesting CEO’s be more bashful. The core issue, especially in fin de siecle economic times, is how an audience can judge the message a leader communications in terms of a balance between individual hubris and real company vision. What will they perceive when he speaks? Guerrera states the dilemma:
The problem is that one man’s egomaniac is another’s visionary and investors
have no way of precisely gauging a CEO’s vision or weighing up their egos.
But there’s a straightforward yardstick by which to understand them. First we must be clear about the myth of Narcissus. I know of no better definition than that offered by Adi Da Samraj on page 94 of The Knee of Listening:
He is the ancient one visible in the Greek myth, who was the universal adored child of the gods, who rejected the loved-one and every form of love and relationship, and who was finally condemned to the contemplation of his own image–until, as a result of his own act and obstinacy, he suffered the fate of eternal separation and died in infinite solitude.
Edelman picked up the clue that the Narcissist avoids relationship. Judging a CEO by how effectively he builds partnerships (with his management team, employees, suppliers and customers) can reveal the extent to which the leader recognizes the contribution others make to the success of the company.
Next, the extent to which the vision and mission of the organization exists independent of the CEO’s ego is simple to determine. Ask how far down the organization the defining vision of the company has percolated? Does the CEO rise to the challenge of internal communications? The guys with the outsized egos often don’t like mixing with the troops. Do they obstinately refuse suggestions they leave the eternal separation of the C-Suite to speak to the cubical crowd? The best won’t miss an opportunity. Hint: Ask how often the CEO eats in the company cafeteria.
Of course, judging a CEO’s effectiveness in terms of the myth of Narcissus is only one way to look at things. Equally rewarding is the well-known concept of the alpha male.
The next FT article I came across (I don’t get all my ideas from the FT, just most of the better ones…) was today’s review of the book Alpha Male by Kate Ludeman and Eddie Erlandson. This husband and wife team are executive coaches who’ve worked with 1,500 CEO’s. They see the need for those at the top to exhibit confidence and charisma. But they warn:
A great deal of wreckage is caused by boys behaving badly. The healthy ones – well-balanced human beings in full command of their alpha strengths – are natural leaders who are trusted by colleagues, respected by competitors, revered by employees and loved by Wall Street. But other alpha males are risks to their organisations – and sometimes to themselves.
Women CEO’s (like those I profiled here) are not the problem. “Alpha women want to lead, but they don’t necessarily need to rule,” the authors say.
Warning signals to look for in your organization include the way the leader runs meetings (a red flag if they are like an episode of The Apprentice). Beware of a leader who creates a climate of fear and suppresses disagreements and stifles open communication.
There’s more tools available from the authors here.
For every Ted Turner and Dennis Kozlowski (who must appreciate infinite solitude more than most these days) there are plenty of examples of decent CEO’s who don’t confuse their identity with the name on the headquarters building. I came across a couple of articles that showcase the best of the breed – strong leaders who make their biggest impression via bottom-line results.
Jurgen Hambrecht CEO of BASF was profiled in the FT on Monday:
Mr. Hambrecht describes his role as that of a “conductor” who makes existing parts and players cohere, not a composer who makes and sells something new. “A chemical company doesn’t need a pop star boss,” he says. Indeed, there is no apparent flamboyance to Mr. Hambrecht, who turned 60 last week. With a gaunt runner’s physique, he is used to straight talking. . . “You can’t really associate anything BASF has done in the past three years solely with my person,” he says.
Of course, it could be argued that Germany has an extreme aversion to leaders with outsized egos since things went pear-shaped for the last major player on April 30, 1945.
One of the classic case studies in contrasting management styles has to be playing out at Hewlett-Packard.
Management consultant Tony Paradiso cast a critical eye on some outsized ego’s in a recent article. He then observes the stark contrast in style and performance between the current HP CEO and his predecessor:
After ridding themselves of the self-absorb (sic) Fiorina, Hewlett-Packard hired Hurd. That was a priceless decision. Unlike his predecessor, Hurd didn’t feature himself in an advertising campaign. In fact, he purposefully kept a low public relations profile. Silly Mark; instead of directing his PR department to hype his arrival, he simply did his job. That involved laying thousands off and restructuring the company. The result: Exceeding financial expectations for five consecutive quarters.
My hope is that fewer of the captains of industry will fall prey to the cautions of Agamemnon and more will heed Beatrice’s wisdom:
What fire is in mine ears? Can this be true?
Stand I condemn’d for pride and scorn so much?
Contempt, farewell! and maiden pride, adieu!
No glory lives behind the back of such.Shakespeare: Much Ado About Nothing: III, i
I’m currently enjoying a great series of podcasts delivered over the past year at the Stanford University School of Engineering and sponsored by the VC firm Draper Fisher Jurvetson, BASES (a student entrepreneurship group), Stanford Technology Ventures Program, and the Department of Management Science and Engineering.
You can find this series on the iTunes Music Store under the Education category (second screen, 4th row down) or via this direct link.
There are 25 hour-long presentations on file. All available for free download. The presenters and topics they cover offer a fascinating look at the personalities and checkered history that makes up Silicon Valley. The audience of Stanford students hears from and asks questions of executives who have been there and done that in terms of surviving and thriving in the Silicon Valley ecosystem — a place where failure is a badge of success and people talk of ‘dog years’ of experience.
I’ve started by listening to three amazing women CEO’s:

Carol Bartz, Executive Chairman of the Board and CEO of Autodesk for the past 14 years, reflecting on her experience of running one of the largest PC software companies in the world while finding a balance between her career and personal life. She also stresses the importance of continued learning and addresses the challenges of succeeding in a global market.

Kim Polese, CEO of SpikeSource describing her twenty years of experience in developing software in Silicon Valley including Java development with Sun Microsystems and the open source community.

Janice Fraser, CEO and a founding partner of Adaptive Path, discussing the entrepreneurial leadership qualities that have contributed to the success of her user experience consulting company.
I worked in Carol Bartz’s sales organization at Sun back in the 1990’s and also saw Kim present at Sun when she was the original Java Product Manager before she went off to found Marimba.
All three women executives admit to being ‘girl geeks’ who embraced science and technology in college and often followed a serendipitous career to the top.
All share incredible insights about starting and growing a high-tech company. They speak with clarity, from the heart, about what motivated them and what they’ve observed. Things as simple as asking the customers what they use the product for (which Bartz says precious few of the staff at Autodesk knew before she arrived and started asking). Issues around the ways to partner for success in the world of Web 2.0 and Open Source (which Polese and Fraser are adept at). The importance of networks, intuition, planning, listening, leading, arguing, anticipating.
Rather than try and write a précis of each person’s material I’d just encourage anyone with an interest in executive communications to simply download and listen. Here’s some killer quotes to whet your appetite.
Bartz:
Don’t be afraid of doing a lot of lateral things. A career as a ladder is a very unsteady concept compared to a pyramid — you have no foundation.
Polese:
There’s nothing more fun than being on a mission together with a team of people building something innovative, breaking new ground and really making a difference in the world. What could be more fun? Not many things in life. And that’s one of the reasons why Silicon Valley is such as great place to build a career and just to live and be.
Fraser:
Being an entrepreneur is not a job, it’s a way of life. It’s a mission more than it is a job. I’m not employed by a company I’m employed by an industry. I’m employed by an ecosystem of people who believe in me and who support me and who I support in turn.
Garr Reynolds’ comments on best practices in executive communications are insightful. He compliments 8-Ball Seth Godin on a masterful speech that’s well worth investing 20 minutes of your time to watch. He reinforces the value of close study of Edward Tufte’s work on PowerPoint and recommends the essay by Stanford professor Jean-Luc Doumont on The cognitive style of PowerPoint: slides are not all evil.(APPLIED THEORY).
Garr concludes with some sage advice:
If I were CEO of a large Silicon Valley company, I’d send my people to Tufte and Edwards, (Toastmasters, Bert Decker, etc.) and send my big presentation projects to Duarte Design. Tools matter, but better design education matters more. When the electricity goes off, who will remain the most effective communicators? As Alan Kay says, “Most ideas you can do pretty darn well with a stick in the sand.”
Great advice that I heartily second.
Somewhat predictably, I’ve decided to move on to the second blog listed on my NSA Blogroll. Bill Conerly’s Businomics Blog

Blogging since: January, 2006
Posting Frequency: 2-3 times weekly
Post Length: 200-300 words average
Aesthetic Appeal: Standard template. Data graphs mix a variety of styles. Baby blue surround.
Graphics: Bar and Line graphs that supplement the text. Click for larger image.
Categories: Books, Business Strategy, Economic News, Investments, Public Policy
Blogroll: 14 economics blogs
Target Audience: Business strategists in large and medium sized companies
Comments allowed: Yes
Trackbacks: Yes
Alexa.com traffic ranking: N/A
Sites that link to this blog: N/A
Yahoo Links: 88
Review:
Dr. Bill Conerly is a heavyweight academic and highly qualified economic advisor. He’s new to blogging this year, and he’s off to a racing start.
He runs a consulting practice, helping business leaders make more profitable decisions through a better understanding of the economy. He’s co-author of Thinking Economics, a high school textbook in multimedia format used in 24 states. His new book, Businomics, will be published in 2007 by Adams Media. His articles are required reading in graduate courses at MIT and Wharton.
This is a blog that promises the reader Better Decisions Through A Better Understanding of the Economy. Read his posts for the skinny on topics such as consumer confidence, employment trends, interest rates, housing and producer pricing. These are meat and potatoes topics for all economists. What’s different are the ‘Business Strategy Implications’ that Bill often concludes each posting with. Example:
Housing supply chain should REALLY hunker down now. Sellers of interest sensitive big-ticket items (like car dealers) should BEGIN to hunker down. The rest of the business community should start thinking about contingency plans for a recession or economic slowdown.
Bill’s blog is also a good place to look for references to books, articles and studies in the area of economics.
On the technical front Bill has had some trouble with lost archives. He might want to use a redirect to mask his generic Typepad URL. He should also incorporate Technorati tags to increase his visibility to search engines.
Reading this blog reminds me of the quote attributed to Lyndon Johnson:
Did you ever think that making a speech on economics is a lot like pissing down your leg? It seems hot to you, but it never does to anyone else.
Bill is no Jim Cramer and I did not see any “Buy Gold!!!” or “Sell Wal-Mart!!!” recommendations, which is a good thing. At the same time, it would be nice to see a little more juice in his posts. Rather than adopting a textbook tone, Bill could lighten things up with insights on our quotidian experience from the perspective of an economist.
Example: In addition to the overall advice on the effect of a housing price drop (above) he could follow-up with comments on markets like the San Francisco Bay Area contrasted with the rural Dakotas – what strategic differences might affect those of us who live there? How do the strategic shifts affect the young, middle aged and older homeowner? How about the business strategy for Realtors or those who service them in these two areas? And if I have a variable interest rate and a daughter going to an Ivy League in the Fall is it time to move to a rental unit?
I’d also like to read about Bill’s experiences as an economist who is also a speaker – what reception do his audiences give him? What content and delivery techniques does he employ to keep their attention and disprove President Johnson’s claim?
This is a blog for those who don’t want to get their economic strategy from the Booyah Bullhorn on Mad Money. Check it out.
I feel like the proverbial latecomer to the party, but I’ve just discovered the wonders of YouTube.
This is a social Web site that allows users to upload, view, and share video clips. The tagline is “Broadcast yourself”. It was founded in February 2005 and has experienced phenomenal growth. 65,000 sub-10 minute video clips are uploaded and 100 million clips are watched each and every day. It’s estimated the company’s bandwidth costs are $1 million a month.
So what did I find so amazing about the site?
It was not the excruciating amateur home video, the garage bands, frat parties and stupid pet tricks. But buried in those million clips is content that I relish:
So here, as a total indulgence, is three minutes of Roy Harper, who is an obscure and wonderfully poetic chap with a guitar and an attitude, celebrating One of Those In England:
and here is, literally, a trip down memory lane, an abstract wonder of out-of-focus home video of a Cheshire road I cycled every day from the age of 11 to 18 with the hoar-frost clinging to the hawthorn hedges:
Explore YouTube – you never know what you might discover!
Peter Schweizer’s recent article on the apparent hypocrisy of Al Gore championing climate change in his Inconvenient Truth movie while living in three homes and flying in private jets raises some interesting questions.
As I noted in my review of the film, Gore’s travel schedule imposes a beefy carbon footprint, but given the urgency of his message may be justified.
Schweizer ad hominem critique highlights a number of areas where he claims Gore’s personal behavior is hypocritical:
Schweizer concludes:
Maybe our very existence isn’t threatened.
.
.
The issue here is not simply Gore’s hypocrisy; it’s a question of credibility. If he genuinely believes the apocalyptic vision he has put forth, and calls for radical changes in the way other people live, why hasn’t he made any radical change in his life? Giving up one of his homes is not asking much, given that he wants the rest of us to radically change our lives.
I think these are cheap shots. Asserting that someone’s argument is wrong because of something discreditable about the person rather than addressing the soundness of the argument itself is a classic logical fallacy.
Consider. Gore has an important message he is trying to deliver across the planet. He can’t do this effectively if he was to travel by bicycle to talk to audiences. Flying in a private jet is environmentally damaging, but the captains of industry do it daily. If he is to be effective he can’t have one hand tied behind his back.
Secondly, the homes he owns are not a-typical of those owned by the elite in America. If he was to sell them and move into modest housing someone else would be burning energy to heat and cool them. What’s he to do, demolish them? Better he stays and tries to run them energy-efficiently.
Finally, any of us with a diversified 401(k) have shares in mining and petroleum companies. Of course, we could sacrifice returns and stay with socially responsible funds, but these often underperform the market.
The response that is needed to global warming is not necessarily to adopt a hair-shirt lifestyle. American public opinion is not receptive to those who’ve tried this. The reputation of Ralph Nader, President Carter and “Governor Moonbeam” Brown of California were not helped by their nods to personal sacrifice and low rent accouterments.
It’s not Gore’s personal lifestyle that’s in question. Rather, it’s the potential impact of climate change on a global scale. He’s done an excellent job communicating the urgency of this in his book and movie. Tripping him up for not living up to the suggestions he made to reduce carbon emissions distracts from the scale of change that is really needed.
Sure, we all need to try and reduce our carbon footprint. And those of us lucky enough to live in advanced economies will need to adjust our material consumption downward by a significant amount. The small percentage of the world’s population that live in the United States cannot continue to consume many times our fair share of energy resources.
Personal choices made by Americans play a role in helping the planet. But serious policy changes (for instance in the CAFE standards for average gas consumption) have a much larger effect. These changes will occur due to legislation resulting from democratic debate as the scale of the crisis unfolds.
Even larger changes will result in response to global forces unleashed by the rest of the world against those who foul the planet. A terrorist campaign with roots in the climatically dispossessed is not unthinkable. The way we deal with it is worth consideration.
And the largest role of all will be played by the planet. Once the ice melts and sea levels rise there probably won’t be a home in America that only has one family living it in. Refugees from the coasts will be billeted in the all of the Gore’s fancy residences. The water lapping at the doors of the Hoover Institution will give Peter Schweizer more concern than Gore’s personal lifestyle.